5.0

So oogy gooey and peanut buttery. YUM. Loved the Reese’s pieces and overall texture and flavor. Was scraping the bottom of the container with this one!

Jennifer Brown

5.0

I love this as a snack when I’m craving Reese’s. It’s a great alternative to keep me moving towards my goals and still have a treat!

Heather H

Oatmeal Scream Pie Peanut Butter

Name: Oatmeal Scream Pie Peanut Butter
Brand: American Dream Nut Butter
Price: 14 USD
Availability: InStock

$ 14.99

oatmeal cookie flavor · vanilla frosting · whole cookie on top

Creamy peanut butter with warm oatmeal cookie flavor, topped with vanilla frosting, white chocolate chips, and an ENTIRE oatmeal cream-filled cookie. That chewy childhood pie flavor, now spoonable. Seasonal.

One Time Delivery Subscribe & Save

You selected a one-time purchase.

Save up to 10% off with subscribe and save.

Why not switch and save more?

Up to 10% off regular price

Never run out

VIP list for promos & discounts

Edit, skip, cancel anytime

give us a try

1 Jar $ 14.99 each most popular

2 Jars SAVE 7% $ 13.94 each best value

3 Jars SAVE 10% $ 13.49 each

Ships Every 4 Weeks (Change Anytime)

Macro friendly

Vegan options

Gluten-free options

Protein packed

Limited Time Only

Grab our 3 most-loved jars + a Free Mystery Baby Butter ($7.99 value)

Don't Start With Just One

$ 57

LEARN MORE

Limited Time Only

Starting at

$ 57

LEARN MORE

So good, it’s scary.

Our newest indulgence is here to haunt your cravings — in the best way possible.

Oatmeal Scream Pie Peanut Butter is a spooky-sweet twist on your favorite childhood treat, blending creamy peanut butter with warm oatmeal cookie flavor and generously topped with creamy vanilla frosting, white chocolate chips and an ENTIRE oatmeal cream filled cookie.

It’s that chewy oatmeal pie flavor you loved as a kid, reimagined as a spoon-able dessert spread you’ll want to keep all to yourself.

ROASTED PEANUTS, CARAMEL CHOCOLATE CANDIES (SUGAR, COCOA BUTTER, MILK, CHOCOLATE, LACTOSE, SOY LECITHIN, CORN SYRUP, PALM OIL, COCOA POWDER PROCESSED WITH ALKALI, BARLEY MALT EXTRACT, SALT, EGG WHITES, ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR), CARAMEL SAUCE (CORN SYRUP, SUGAR, MILK, SALT, NATURAL FLAVOR, PECTIN, DISODIUM PHOSPHATE), SUGAR, SEA SALT.
ALLERGY INFORMATION: CONTAINS PEANUTS, SOY, MILK, WHEAT, EGG. MADE IN A FACILITY THAT ALSO PROCESSES ALMONDS, CASHEWS AND PEANUTS.

Serving size: 2tbsp

Calories: 150

Fat: 11g

Carbs: 11g

Protein: 5g

Sugar: 6g

Our small batch butters retain peak freshness for up to 1 year if unopened; 6 months when opened.
Please note, product will not arrive exactly as pictured as toppings will settle during transit...give it a good stir and enjoy!
Specialty blends featuring chocolate toppings may experience some melting if shipped to warmer climates. Please note, product will not arrive exactly as pictured as toppings will settle during transit...give it a good stir and enjoy!

Oatmeal Cream Pie

Sooo delicious! I didn’t stir it up like I should but will definitely next time I buy a jar. A huge chunk of oatmeal cream pie is in the jar and you have to break it up and stir the butter rly good. 10/10

The Oatmeal butter was ok. There was one whole, in-tact, oatmeal pie in the jar drowned in PB. The PB taste over powers the oatmeal pie. I added more oatmeal pies of my own to balance it out. The M is for Monster tasted like the stale cookies inside. Glad I ordered the sampler of that one.

This is soo good , the flavor , the toppings are outstanding !!

We bought four different flavors. We’ve bought from them before. I don’t know if they’re trying to cut costs or what one of the cookie butters the monster cookie butter mix was a extremely scant topping in it. It was like 90% just peanut butter. And more watery than what I remember.

Best Flavor Award

Oatmeal Scream Pie is one of the staples from ADNB. Don't sleep on this flavor!

1 2 3

The Secret Behind Every Spoonful

This isn't the peanut butter you had as a kid, but you'll wish it was. Cookie dough, brownies, cheesecake, cinnamon rolls and dessert flavor in every spoonful.

Because cravings hit harder when you're trying to be good. That's why we built our nut butters to satisfy both your taste buds and your goals.

Life's too short for plain peanut butter. So we load every jar with cookies, candies, swirls and crunch. Because no one sneaks into the pantry for ordinary.