Contact Us

Have a question? Feel free to contact us!

We’ve compiled all of your most-asked questions into our FAQ portal here. We hope you find this resource helpful and encourage you to use this as your starting point when you are in need of a quick response to some common questions.

You can send American Dream Nut Butter an e-mail with your questions or comments to

At this time we are experiencing increased customer outreach related to COVID-19. Please allow our Customer Advocate team up to 48 business hours to respond back to your request. Our business hours are 9:00AM and 5:00PM Eastern Standard Time, Monday through Friday, except holidays.

Butter Shop Address & Hours
Local to Indiana? We are working on building out a storefront and offer limited ability for local residents to coordinate pick-up of orders. Please contact Customer Support if you feel this may apply to you.

The Butter Shop is open from 8:00AM - 3:00PM EST, Monday through Friday and can be reached directly at 317-462-4151. Please note; this line is not set-up to accommodate customer service requests; please submit support needs via the email listed above. 

Additionally, if you are filling out a USPS Claim, donation request, sending Butter Fam fan mail, etc. please be sure to use our official address:

 American Mayhem LLC (dba American Dream Nut Butter)
4202 N Ems Blvd
Suite 100
Greenfield, IN 46140


Collabs, Giveaways & More
To inquire about product collaborations and sponsored giveaways, please contact

To learn more about the official Ambassador Program at American Dream Nut Butter, please visit our Ambassadors page here

Please note we receive hundreds of solicitations and collaboration messages daily, so kindly allow our team up to 48 hours to respond back to your initial inquiry.

Recognize a Veteran
At American Dream Nut Butter, we recognize that this country is built upon the sacrifice of our American Heroes, which is why we are proud to recognize veteran and active duty officers serving our country. Each month we package jars of our handcrafted, gourmet nut butter to be sent out to our American Heroes here in the U.S. and stationed overseas. Want to recognize someone? Let us know! Email to nominate a hero today!