Fraud Blocker
Highest Protein Nut Butter on the Market! SHOP NOW
My Wishlist

Oatmeal Scream Pie Almond Butter

$ 16.99

A childhood favorite reimagined. Oatmeal Scream Pie Almond Butter combines soft oatmeal cookie flavor, sweet vanilla frosting, white chocolate chips, and an entire oatmeal cream-filled cookie for the ultimate nostalgic treat.

You selected a one-time purchase.

Save up to 10% off with subscribe and save.

Why not switch and save more?
Up to 10% off regular price
Never run out
VIP list for promos & discounts
Edit, skip, cancel anytime
Only 9 Left, Get Yours Now!

Macro friendly

Vegan options

Gluten-free options

Protein packed

Limited Time Only
Fan Favorite Stack Peanut Butter
Grab our 3 most-loved jars + a Free Mystery Baby Butter ($7.99 value)
Don't Start With Just One
$ 57
LEARN MORE
Limited Time Only
Starting at
$ 57
LEARN MORE

Oatmeal Scream Pie Almond Butter đŸ‘»đŸȘ

One bite will have you feeling like a kid again.

Inspired by the classic oatmeal cream cookie, Oatmeal Scream Pie Almond Butter starts with our smooth, small-batch almond butter infused with soft oatmeal cookie flavor and warm brown sugar notes. Every jar is hand-finished with creamy vanilla frosting, premium white chocolate chips, and an entire oatmeal cream-filled cookie for the perfect balance of chewy cookie, sweet filling, and creamy almond butter.

It’s everything you loved about opening that lunchbox treat—only even better by the spoonful.

Whether you’re celebrating spooky season or simply craving a nostalgic dessert, this limited-edition flavor is guaranteed to disappear fast.

Perfect For

  • Eating straight from the spoon
  • Graham crackers and pretzels
  • Apple slices and bananas
  • Toast and English muffins
  • Oatmeal and yogurt
  • Ice cream and dessert toppings

Part of our Almond Unlock Vault Collection, these retired fan favorites have been unlocked for a limited time. Once the vault closes, they’ll disappear until their next return.

ROASTED ALMONDS, OATMEAL CREAM PIE (CORN SYRUP, ENRICHED BLEACHED FLOUR [WHEAT FLOUR, BARLEY MALT, NIACIN, REDUCED IRON, VITAMIN B1, VITAMIN B2, FOLIC ACID], PALM OIL, SOYBEAN OIL, WHOLE GRAIN ROLLED OATS, MOLASSES, RAISIN PASTE, SUGAR, DEXTROSE, BAKING SODA, AMMONIUM BICARBONATE, SODIUM ALUMINUM PHOSPHATE, WHEY, SALT, SOY LECITHIN, CORN STARCH, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL FLAVORS, MONO- AND DIGLYCERIDES, POLYSORBATE 60, SORBITAN MONOSTEARATE, DRIED EGGS, MODIFIED CORN STARCH, SORBIC ACID, SOY FLOUR, ANNATTO EXTRACT, BETA CAROTENE, CARAMEL COLOR, CHOCOLATE, COCOA BUTTER, CITRIC ACID, COCOA PROCESSED WITH ALKALI, HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP, MODIFIED WHEAT STARCH, NONFAT DRY MILK, PECTIN, POLYSORBATE 80, PROPYLENE GLYCOL MONOSTEARATE, RED 40 LAKE, RICE FLOUR, SODIUM CITRATE, SODIUM STEAROYL LACTYLATE, TBHQ, TITANIUM DIOXIDE, TURMERIC EXTRACT), WHITE CHOCOLATE CHIPS (SUGAR, PALM OIL, MILK, SOY LECITHIN, ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR), VANILLA FILLING (SUGAR, PALM OIL, SOYBEAN OIL, CORN SYRUP, MONO AND DIGLYCERIDES, POLYSORBATE 60, ARTIFICIAL COLOR, SALT, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR, MILK, POTASSIUM SORBATE, SODIUM BENZOATE, GUAR GUM, CITRIC ACID, FD&C [YELLOW #5, BLUE #1]), SUGAR, SEA SALT.

CONTAINS ALMONDS, SOY, MILK, WHEAT, EGG. MADE IN A FACILITY THAT ALSO PROCESSES ALMONDS, CASHEWS AND PEANUTS.

Serving size:

Calories:

Fat:

Carbs:

Protein:

Sugar:

Naturally low in sugar, our butter base is sweetened lightly with Stevia. The only added sugars you’ll find will come from our hand-measured and hand-topped mix-ins! Please refer to our nutritional label for detailed allergen and ingredient information.

We use a wide variety of all-natural flavorings and extracts including butter, cocoa and vanilla. No artificial sweeteners added.

Our small batch butters retain peak freshness for up to 1 year if unopened; 6 months when opened.

Please note, product will not arrive exactly as pictured as toppings will settle during transit...give it a good stir and enjoy!

Specialty blends featuring chocolate toppings may experience some melting if shipped to warmer climates. Please note, product will not arrive exactly as pictured as toppings will settle during transit...give it a good stir and enjoy!

Customer Reviews

Based on 170 reviews
79%
(134)
9%
(16)
2%
(4)
1%
(2)
8%
(14)
M
Melanie

Super delicious! Loved it!

N
Nathaniel K
So Good It's Scary

I can see why it is a returning favorite and may be reordered in the future. The already delicious base topped with a cream filled oatmeal cookie? A reason to scream for joy, even if it is just doing so in your head.

S
Sandra S.
Love it

Love it

R
Rose N.
So good!

So good!

G
Gina D.
OMG - I’ve falllen in

OMG - I’ve falllen in love. Just spectacular. Unlike any nut butter I’ve eaten before. Quite unique.

The Secret Behind Every Spoonful

This isn't the peanut butter you had as a kid, but you'll wish it was. Cookie dough, brownies, cheesecake, cinnamon rolls and dessert flavor in every spoonful.

Because cravings hit harder when you're trying to be good. That's why we built our nut butters to satisfy both your taste buds and your goals.

Life's too short for plain peanut butter. So we load every jar with cookies, candies, swirls and crunch. Because no one sneaks into the pantry for ordinary.

why 1 Million+ happy customers love our nut butters

protein that actually tastes good

Up to 12g protein per serving. No chalky shakes required.

Dessert in disguise

Cookie dough, cheesecake, brownies, and more.

Spoonable straight from the jar

No gritty texture. Just drippy, drizzly perfection.

Goals Meet Cravings

High protein, lower sugar and real dessert flavor.

There's a butter for every body

Peanut, almond cashew with gluten-free and vegan options.

6 million jars and counting

Loved by customers nationwide for over 8years.

Products You May Love

Cake Batter Ice Cream Crunch Cashew Butter Cake Batter Ice Cream Crunch Cashew Butter
Cake Batter Ice Cream Crunch Cashew Butter
Gluten-Free Options
$ 16.99
Gluten-Free Thicka Than a Snicka Peanut Butter Gluten-Free Thicka Than a Snicka Peanut Butter
Gluten-Free Thicka Than a Snicka Peanut Butter
$ 16.99
Breanne’s Blend Death By Chocolate Peanut Butter Breanne’s Blend Death By Chocolate Peanut Butter
Breanne’s Blend Death By Chocolate Peanut Butter
Gluten-Free Options
$ 17.49
Breanne’s Blend A Twixted Treat Peanut Butter Breanne’s Blend A Twixted Treat Peanut Butter
Breanne’s Blend A Twixted Treat Peanut Butter
Gluten-Free Options
$ 17.49
Marshmallow Cookie Dough Delight Cashew Butter Marshmallow Cookie Dough Delight Cashew Butter
Marshmallow Cookie Dough Delight Cashew Butter
Gluten-Free Options
$ 16.99
Cake Batter Ice Cream Crunch Cashew Butter Cake Batter Ice Cream Crunch Cashew Butter
Cake Batter Ice Cream Crunch Cashew Butter
Gluten-Free Options
$ 16.99
Gluten-Free Thicka Than a Snicka Peanut Butter Gluten-Free Thicka Than a Snicka Peanut Butter
Gluten-Free Thicka Than a Snicka Peanut Butter
$ 16.99
Breanne’s Blend Death By Chocolate Peanut Butter Breanne’s Blend Death By Chocolate Peanut Butter
Breanne’s Blend Death By Chocolate Peanut Butter
Gluten-Free Options
$ 17.49
Breanne’s Blend A Twixted Treat Peanut Butter Breanne’s Blend A Twixted Treat Peanut Butter
Breanne’s Blend A Twixted Treat Peanut Butter
Gluten-Free Options
$ 17.49
SHOP NOW