5.0

So oogy gooey and peanut buttery. YUM. Loved the Reese’s pieces and overall texture and flavor. Was scraping the bottom of the container with this one!

Jennifer Brown

5.0

I love this as a snack when I’m craving Reese’s. It’s a great alternative to keep me moving towards my goals and still have a treat!

Heather H

Bewitched Peanut Butter

Name: Bewitched Peanut Butter
Brand: American Dream Nut Butter
Price: 15 USD
Availability: InStock

$ 15.99

Chocolate ‘n peanut butter lovers, do we have an EERIE-sistible new treat for you! It’s cocoa-y, it’s creamy

Regular Gluten-Free

Macro friendly

Vegan options

Gluten-free options

Protein packed

Limited Time Only

Grab our 3 most-loved jars + a Free Mystery Baby Butter ($7.99 value)

Don't Start With Just One

$ 57

LEARN MORE

Limited Time Only

Starting at

$ 57

LEARN MORE

Chocolate and peanut butter lovers, prepare to be completely bewitched.

Bewitched Peanut Butter begins with a rich, chocolatey sandwich cookie–flavored peanut butter that’s creamy, cocoa-packed and just sweet enough. Each jar is hand-topped with crushed chocolate sandwich cookies, festive Halloween sprinkles and a touch of sea salt for the perfect balance of sweet, salty and hauntingly delicious.

Smooth, chocolatey and loaded with cookie crunch, it’s the kind of spell you’ll happily fall under.

Why You’ll Love It

✔ Chocolate sandwich cookie–flavored peanut butter
✔ Crushed chocolate sandwich cookies
✔ Festive Halloween sprinkles
✔ A touch of sea salt
✔ 8g of protein per serving
✔ Just 3g of sugar per serving

Bewitched has risen from the ADNB vault for Night of the Living Butters—but only for a limited time.

*Seasonal limited edition

GLUTEN-FREE INGREDIENTS:
ROASTED PEANUTS, WHEY PROTEIN (WHEY PROTEIN ISOLATE, NATURAL FLAVORS, STEVIA), GLUTEN FREE CHOCOLATE SANDWICH COOKIES (SUGAR, TAPIOCA SYRUP, WHITE RICE FLOUR, PALM OIL, CANOLA OIL, OAT FLOUR, PEA STARCH, POTATO STARCH, MILK, COCOA POWDER, CORNSTARCH, CASSAVA FLOUR, TAPIOCA STARCH, PEA PROTEIN, SALT, NATURAL FLAVOR, PEA FIBER, SOY LECITHIN, SOYBEAN OIL, POTATO FLOUR, SUNFLOWER LECITHIN, BAKING SODA, XANTHAN GUM, CHOCOLATE, INULIN, SODIUM BICARBONATE, MODIFIED CELLULOSE, ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR), SPRINKLES (SUGAR, CORNSTARCH, PALM OIL, SOY LECITHIN, GUM ARABIC, CONFECTIONER’S GLAZE, FD&C [YELLOW #6 LAKE, YELLOW #5, YELLOW #5 LAKE, BLUE #1 LAKE, RED #40 LAKE, RED #3], VANILLA).

CONTAINS PEANUTS, MILK, SOY. MADE IN A FACILITY THAT ALSO PROCESSES ALMONDS, CASHEWS AND PEANUTS.

REGULAR INGREDIENTS:
ROASTED PEANUTS, WHEY PROTEIN (WHEY PROTEIN ISOLATE, NATURAL FLAVORS, STEVIA), CHOCOLATE SANDWICH COOKIES (UNBLEACHED ENRICHED FLOUR [WHEAT FLOUR, NIACIN, REDUCED IRON, VITAMIN B1, VITAMIN B2, FOLIC ACID], SUGAR, CANOLA OIL, PALM OIL, COCOA, BAKING SODA, CALCIUM PHOSPHATE, SOY LECITHIN, SALT, CHOCOLATE, NATURAL FLAVOR), SPRINKLES (SUGAR, CORNSTARCH, PALM OIL, SOY LECITHIN, GUM ARABIC, CONFECTIONER’S GLAZE, FD&C [YELLOW #6 LAKE, YELLOW #5, YELLOW #5 LAKE, BLUE #1 LAKE, RED #40 LAKE, RED #3], VANILLA).

CONTAINS PEANUTS, MILK, SOY, WHEAT. MADE IN A FACILITY THAT ALSO PROCESSES ALMONDS, CASHEWS AND PEANUTS.

Serving size: 2tbsp

Calories: 150

Fat: 11g

Carbs: 7g

Protein: 8g

Sugar: 3g

Our small batch, handcrafted Bewitched Peanut Butter gets an extra dose of clean protein from our premium, grassfed, lactose-free whey. Naturally low in sugar, our butter base is sweetened lightly with Stevia. The only added sugars you’ll find will come from our hand-measured and hand-topped mix-ins! Please refer to our nutritional label for detailed allergen and ingredient information.

We use a wide variety of all-natural flavorings and extracts including butter, cocoa and vanilla. No artificial sweeteners added.

Our small batch butters retain peak freshness for up to 1 year if unopened; 6 months when opened.

Please note, product will not arrive exactly as pictured as toppings will settle during transit...give it a good stir and enjoy!

Specialty blends featuring chocolate toppings may experience some melting if shipped to warmer climates. Please note, product will not arrive exactly as pictured as toppings will settle during transit...give it a good stir and enjoy!

Ugh, I should’ve known better! I’ve realized I’m just not a fan of chocolate-based peanut butter. It has a weird bitter taste to me. I also expected more cookie.

Hi Breanna,

We are really sorry to hear the chocolate peanut butter wasn’t a hit for you! We know everyone’s taste buds are different, and not every flavor is going to be a perfect match.
We do carefully measure all our toppings to stay consistent with our nutrition labels, but we are sorry the cookie flavor didn’t live up to what you were hoping for. The good news is we have lots of other flavors to choose from, and we’d be happy to help you find one you’ll love!

Peanut butter

This is sooo good I couldn't believe the chunks of goodies that was in it. Can't eat a lot at 1 time but it's so worth getting!!

I still have not received

I still have not received my delivery after 3 weeks

Not super chocolatey or peanut butter flavor, lots of mix ins

1 2 3

The Secret Behind Every Spoonful

This isn't the peanut butter you had as a kid, but you'll wish it was. Cookie dough, brownies, cheesecake, cinnamon rolls and dessert flavor in every spoonful.

Because cravings hit harder when you're trying to be good. That's why we built our nut butters to satisfy both your taste buds and your goals.

Life's too short for plain peanut butter. So we load every jar with cookies, candies, swirls and crunch. Because no one sneaks into the pantry for ordinary.