Peanut Butter
Cashew Butter
Almond Butter
Indulgent Butters
All Nut Butters
Highest Protein
Butter Bundles
Sample Sizes
On-The-Go Packs!
Gifting
Available Now
GLP-1 Friendly Nut Butters
Loved by Over 900k Happy Customers
GHOSTS OF
CHRISTMAS PAST
GHOSTS OF CHRISTMAS PAST
8 holiday favorites. Only here for 5 days.
Pre-order yours before the timer ends!
Back for the Holidays
These Christmas favorites are available for pre-order! Scoop yours now, and we'll have them on their way to you within 2 weeks.
Gluten-Free Naughty or Nice Cashew Butter
Peppermint Dreams Cashew Butter
Nutcracker Crunch Cashew Butter
Candy Cane Kisses Peanut Butter
Santa’s Magic Peanut Butter
Merry Little Cake Indulgent Peanut Butter
Gluten-Free Scotcharoos Peanut Butter
White Chocolate Snickerdoodle Almond Butter
Only One Gets to Stay!
Every jar purchased = one vote. The best-selling flavor earns a spot on the menu for the rest of the holiday season! The other seven head back to the Vault.
Which Flavor Will Stay for Christmas?
No Restocks. No Surprise Returns.
This is the only time you can order these seasonal nut butters. Once the timer ends, they head back to the vault.
How it works
Pre-Order Now
Choose your favorite flavors. No
limit on how many jars you can order.
The Vault Closes
Once the timer ends, we'll begin
making your orders right away.
Ships in 2 Weeks
Your order is made fresh in small
batches and shipped within 2 weeks. Worth the wait.
Frequently Asked
Questions
Can I order multiple flavors?
+Yes! There's no limit to how many flavors and jars you grab.
Is there a limit on how many jars I can order?
+Nope! Feel free to stock up.
When will I be charged?
+You will be charged at the time of order.
When will my order ship?
+Your order will be shipped within 2 weeks after the pre-order ends.
When do we find out which flavor is staying?
+We'll announce the winning flavor a few days after the timer ends!