Fraud Blocker
Highest Protein Nut Butter on the Market! SHOP NOW
My Wishlist
More Options...
Filter By Tags
Peanut Butter Almond Butter Breanne's Blends Gluten-Free indulgent Protein Macro-Friendly Topping Free Vegan Paws Off new Sample Sizes VIP

More

Peanut Butter

A jar of Sweet Earths All American Apple Pie Peanut Butter sits on a white surface with a white subway tile background. The jar is surrounded by ingredients that make up the product, including whole wheat crackers, white chocolate chips, dried apple pieces, and a sliced apple. A jar of All American Apple Pie Peanut Butter sits on a white tiled surface with a spoon lifting a gooey, apple-pie flavored peanut butter spread. A scoop of vanilla ice cream appears on the left, and whole and sliced apples with cinnamon and cookie crumbs are arranged around the jar.
All American Apple Pie Peanut Butter
Gluten-Free Options
$ 15.99 $ 17.99
A jar of peanut butter topped with red, white, and blue sprinkles sits in front of a pink whipped drink with whipped cream, strawberries, blueberries, and cookie crumbs. A hand is visible holding a spoon above the jar, and the scene is styled with fresh berries, strawberries, raspberries, cookies, and sprinkles on a white surface. A jar of Star Spangled Fluff Peanut Butter sits on a marble surface with whipped cream, strawberries, blueberries, popcorn, and red, white, and blue sprinkles around it. A spoon lifts peanut butter from the jar, and a pink milkshake with whipped cream and sprinkles stands beside it.
Star Spangled Fluff Peanut Butter
Gluten-Free Options
$ 15.99
« Previous 1 2 3

They Love Us

5.0

Delicious!!!

So good, I have to sneak a spoonful when I walk past! Good drizzled over vanilla ice cream.

Katie S

5.0

Favorite Flavor

One of my favorite flavors so far. And as always it is a great pre or post workout snack. It fills you up with lots of protein! I will definitely get this flavor again!

Angela

5.0

Best Yet!

I use to question people who just ate pb by the spoon.. however after sampling a fe this one is the best yet!

A.B.

5.0

Ultimate Favorite!

Out of all the butters I've tried this is my ultimate favorite. It is so good. It was smooth and just tasted like a monster cookie without all the guilt!

Annette

5.0

Best Dang PB ever!!!

I actually add some extra Reece's Pieces to it! I no longer can buy store PB after trying American Dream. Best tasing PB on the market and I keep turning all my friends on to it!

Customer

5.0

YUM.

So oogy gooey and peanut buttery. YUM. Loved the Reese’s pieces and overall texture and flavor. Was scraping the bottom of the container with this one!

Jennifer Brown

More Questions about our Flavored Peanut Butter:

We start with American-grown peanuts, roast and grind them fresh, then flavor the butter itself from scratch to taste like your favorite desserts. These aren’t plain peanut butters with toppings mixed in—the flavor lives in the butter first. From indulgent dessert jars to high-protein blends, every batch is handcrafted for rich flavor, smooth texture, and a true dessert replacement experience.

Yes. Our peanut butter collection includes everything from our highest-protein Breanne’s Blends with grassfed whey protein and added collagen, to vegan and dairy-free peanut butter flavors, topping-free options, and indulgent dessert jars. Whether you’re tracking macros, following GLP-1 or bariatric nutrition, or simply want peanut butter that tastes like dessert, there’s a jar built for you.

Many of our peanut butter flavors are available in certified gluten-free versions. Look for the gluten-free tag on individual product pages. Our nut butter base is made without added oils and unnecessary fillers, while some toppings may contain small amounts of oils, sugars, or food coloring as part of their original ingredients.

We helped pioneer handcrafted flavored nut butter before it became a category. Founded in 2018, American Dream creates flavor inside the butter itself—not just by adding toppings to plain peanut butter. There are a lot of copycats now, but there’s only one original. More than 6 million jars later, we’re still making every batch by hand.