New Flavors Are Here! Get Your Monster Mash Bundle Today! SHOP NOW
My Wishlist
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
Butter My Cup Cookie
5.0
So oogy gooey and peanut buttery. YUM. Loved the Reese’s pieces and overall texture and flavor. Was scraping the bottom of the container with this one!
Jennifer Brown 
5.0
I love this as a snack when I’m craving Reese’s. It’s a great alternative to keep me moving towards my goals and still have a treat!
Heather H 
Chocolate Brownie Collagen Peptides
Our Latest Creation
Collagens Limited Edition
LEARN MORE
Starting at
$ 49.99

Butter My Cup Cookie

$ 7.49

You selected a one-time purchase.
Save up to 15% off with subscribe and save.
Why not switch and save more?

Up to 15% off regular price
Never run out
VIP list for promos & discounts
Edit, skip, cancel anytime
Ships Every 4 Weeks (Change Anytime)

A true peanut butter lover’s dream! We take everything you love about peanut butter cups, and transform it into a decadent, candy-filled peanut butter cookie. Our tasty cookie dough base is ultra thick and chewy, thanks to our handcrafted gourmet peanut butter, and is stuffed with REESE'S® Peanut Butter Cups and REESE'S® Pieces. Deliciously topped with milk chocolate and creamy peanut butter drizzle.

WHEAT FLOUR, BROWN CANE SUGAR, PEANUTS, REESE’S PEANUT BUTTER CUPS (MILK CHOCOLATE (SUGAR, COCOA BUTTER, CHOCOLATE, SKIM MILK, MILK FAT, LACTOSE, SOY LECHITIN, PGPR), PEANUTS, SUGAR, DEXTROSE, SALT, TBHQ AND CITRIC ACID), EGG, CANE SUGAR, MILK CHOCOLATE CHIPS (CANE SUGAR, VEGETABLE OIL, NONFAT DRY MILK, COCOA PROCESSED WITH ALKALI, COCOA, SOY LECITHIN, SALT), BUTTER, MILK, REESE’S PIECES (SUGAR, PARTIALLY DEFATTED PEANUTS, HYDROGENATED VEGETABLE OIL, CORN SYRUP, DEXTROSE, CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF: PALM KERNEL OIL, FD&C (YELLOW 5 LAKE, YELLOW 6 LAKE, RED 40 LAKE, BLUE 1 LAKE), SALT, CONFECTIONER’S GLAZE, SOY LECHITIN, MODIFIED CORNSTARCH, VANILLA, CARNAUBA WAX, MILK) , CORNSTARCH, BAKING POWDER, SEA SALT, BAKING SODA, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL FLAVORS.

CONTAINS WHEAT, PEANUTS, MILK, SOY, EGG.

Made in a facility that also processes almonds, cashews and peanuts

Serving size: 1/2 cookie

Calories: 320

Fat: 14g

Carbs: 44g

Protien: 7g

Sugar: 24g

why 387,000+ Happy Customers love our Nut Butters

Quality Ingredients

Finest nuts for superior flavor and nutrition.

Rich Flavors

Wide range to suit every taste.

Health Benefits

Packed with protein and essential nutrients.

Versatile Use

Ideal for spreading, dipping, baking, or blending.

Sustainable Practices

Environmentally-conscious production.

Customer Care

Committed to customer satisfaction.

What Makes American Dream Nut Butter Different

SMALL BATCH

We hand whip each jar of nut butter, ensuring we never lose that addictive, drippy signature texture we are known for. Fresh made upon ordering you can be sure your taste buds will be delighted.

USA MADE

Our quality is the utmost importance to us which is why we source every ingredient ourselves and even purchase our nuts directly from the farm. We then take all these high quality ingredients and turn them into the magical spread you know and love right here in the Midwest.

ADNB GIVES BACK

We are proud to support our American Heroes and other initiatives close to our hearts. We have sent over 6 thousand jars of nut butter to our American Heroes and donated to more than 40 charities. You can nominate a hero here or read more about our giving back efforts here.