Indulgent Cookies

Mega stuffed, insanely thick, epically chewy. Whether you’re a chocolate lover, fan of fruity pastries or a classic cookies n’ cream fan, we’ve got a cookie for you. Scratch-made, upon order, our Indulgent Cookies offer massive flavor with each bite. The foundation for each cookie begins with a delectable dough built around our silky smooth gourmet nut butters, complemented with just the right amount of premium mix-ins and toppings.

Shop by

Butters Cookies Cakes

More options...

Showing

10 / 10
  • Butter My Cup Cookie
    Butter My Cup Cookie

    Butter My Cup Cookie

    $ 6.49
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Unit price per
  • Gimme S'more Cookie
    Gimme S'more Cookie

    Gimme S'more Cookie

    $ 6.49
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Unit price per
  • Dunk A Spoon Cookie
    Dunk A Spoon Cookie

    Dunk A Spoon Cookie

    $ 6.49
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Unit price per
  • Out of this World Cookie
    Out of this World Cookie

    Out of this World Cookie

    $ 6.49
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Unit price per
  • Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie
    Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie

    Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Cookie

    $ 6.49
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Unit price per
  • Gluten-Free Butter My Cup Cookie
    Gluten-Free Butter My Cup Cookie

    Gluten-Free Butter My Cup Cookie

    $ 7.49
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Unit price per
  • Fudgin' Around Cookie
    Fudgin' Around Cookie

    Fudgin' Around Cookie

    $ 6.49
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Unit price per
  • Starberry Blast Cookie
    Starberry Blast Cookie

    Starberry Blast Cookie

    $ 6.49
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Unit price per
  • Gluten-Free Dunk A Spoon Cookie
    Gluten-Free Dunk A Spoon Cookie

    Gluten-Free Dunk A Spoon Cookie

    $ 7.49
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Unit price per
  • Gluten-Free Starberry Blast Cookie
    Gluten-Free Starberry Blast Cookie

    Gluten-Free Starberry Blast Cookie

    $ 7.49
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Unit price per
x